RSS Feed

Vegan Myths: The “Listening to my Body” Excuse

Posted on

I recently read the post, Can We Please Stop ‘Listening to Our Bodies’? on Huffington Post by Ed Coffin and wanted to share it.  It’s so disappointing to hear a former vegan telling people that they listened to their body telling them that they needed to eat animal products.  If your body needs protein or calcium or whatever you’re using as an excuse, any vegan knows that it is readily available in whole foods.  What’s worse is that anti-vegans use these statements as evidence that vegans are just crazy hippies who haven’t listened to their body’s signals yet.

This happens with simply vegetarians, too, as I found when watching an old episode of the HBO series, Girls.  Lena Dunham’s character, Hannah, tells a guy that she was vegetarian for years, but someone cooked a steak for her, so she ate it and could feel herself getting much needed nourishment from it.  So frustrating to watch.

Anyway, the following post includes a great official statement from the American Dietetic Association about how a balanced vegan diet is perfectly healthy for all stages of life, including pregnancy, which is good to hear.  I also like to see such truthful pro-vegan posts on websites that are not vegetarian-focused.  Way to go, Huffington Post!  Enjoy!

Sure, there are perfectly legitimate reasons to “listen to our bodies.” For example, noticing a sharp chest pain or an allergic reaction (a real, diagnosed one) to food. However, there are many people who make a completely irrational attempt to justify their “need” to consume animal products by using the “listening to my body” argument. As a registered dietitian, this is probably one of the most irksome arguments I hear, because it’s simply untrue.

Thank goodness that we don’t have to rely on mere thoughts and feelings to determine what nutrients humans need to consume to stay healthy. In fact, there’s a thing called the scientific method, and it’s an incredibly precise way of gathering and deciphering information. We have used it to compile decades of nutrition research that have resulted in established recommendations for the nutrients our bodies need to thrive.

We have even been able to use this body of scientific evidence on human nutrition to make the determination that we simply don’t need to consume animal products to survive. The Academy of Nutrition and Dietetics has put this issue to rest in a single position statement:

It is the position of the American Dietetic Association that appropriately planned vegetarian diets, including total vegetarian or vegan diets, are healthful, nutritionally adequate, and may provide health benefits in the prevention and treatment of certain diseases. Well-planned vegetarian diets are appropriate for individuals during all stages of the life cycle, including pregnancy, lactation, infancy, childhood, and adolescence, and for athletes.

Evidence-based nutrition recommendations tell us the appropriate amounts of macro and micronutrients the general population needs to stay nourished. How we choose to obtain those nutrients is completely up to us, and there’s certainly no established recommendation for the amount of animal products we need to consume, because they’re not essential. We can get all the nutrients our bodies require while consuming a completely plant-based diet. This isn’t propaganda or zealotry; it’s a simple scientific fact.

So, let’s please stop using the “listening to my body” excuse, because it’s completely false. Let’s just be truthful and say, “I’m not ready or willing to go vegan at the moment.” There are certainly many debates we can have surrounding the vegan lifestyle, but whether or not we need to eat animal products to be healthy isn’t one of them. No one needs to “listen to their body” to decide if they can go vegan or not.


About mrsnikkiv

I blog to document my experience transitioning to a vegan lifestyle.

4 responses »

  1. I do listen to my body and never have I gotten stronger positive signals than when I became vegetarian! I am a runner and now I never have to deal with that heavy feeling when I go out for a run in the morning!

  2. I never know what to say to someone who tells me that they had to go back to eating meat for health reasons. I even recently found out that the Dali Lama eats meat because his doctors tell him to do so for his health. I was shocked when I found this out. I really don’t get it. Celeste 🙂

    • Yeah, with all the research showing how meat is actually bad for you, I can’t fathom a real medical reason that whatever benefits you could get would outweigh the negatives.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: